Startup vs. Company

"Oh yeah, I've started 6 companies, and right now I have 3 startups going. I just love starting companies. I don't know what's wrong with me...."


Have you ever heard statements like that?


I hear them, fairly often, and I am never sure what to make of them. My immediate impulse is to call "Bullshit", but I don't because part of me admires that attitude. It's just like the moniker "Serial Entrepreneur" seems to have become a status symbol. It doesn't matter if the result of your seriality is that you are broke or forced the indignity of becoming a 'salaryman' at a regular company, oh, like Google. Being a serial Entrepreneur is cool.


I hope you realize that I am being ironic. I happen to think that Google is an amazing company and people who have a job there have it good and have reason to be proud.


So, I enjoyed reading "Startup vs. Company" a blog post by Spencer Fry, with the subtitle "Startups easy. Companies hard.", in which he says, among other things:



"They tried to claim that they were currently working on a half dozen startups (what I'd term "projects"; a startup needs focused development), and as the dispute developed they also insisted that Facebook and Twitter were still startups and not companies. "You can't use the term for everything," I said, "just because it's an online product." Maybe it's a New York vs. San Francisco thing, but in New York we're building companies, not startups. Maybe it's because it costs more to live here, but we're trying to put food on the table, not be on the cover of Business Week." (from Startup vs. Company)



(It will make Scott Kirsner's heart beat faster when he realizes that the conversation being quoted above was between Spencer Fry, from New York, and 'two guys from San Fransisco" about the meaning of the word 'Startup')


I take Spencer Fry's side in this debate. The term 'startup' and 'company', at least in the mouths of our community, have experienced serious devaluation:


"What makes creating a company so difficult is that it's no longer a couple of people sitting around their apartment fine-tuning an idea. Those were the days! It's a team, all working together to solve a complex problem. Then if you're lucky enough to solve it, you have to sell, market, and support it. It starts to get scary.

Building a business is mind numbing when you think about it. You have to be a little insane to venture down this path. Your chances of succeeding are slim, and even if you do succeed you have to continue to innovate or you'll be obsolete in eighteen months." (from Startup vs. Company)

Just something to keep in mind the next time you say or hear a statement like I began with.

Posted on March 23, 2011 and filed under Life, Technology.